Pennsylvania House · 2025–2026 Regular Session
HB 464: Proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, further providing for courts to be open and suits against the Commonwealth.
Appeal of the Chair's Ruling (roll call 2) · May 14, 2025 · Yeas 102, nays 101 · Party-line vote
How each party voted
Speaker Joanna McClinton voted yea.
Bill
- Bill
- HB 464
- Motion
- Appeal of the Chair's Ruling
- Date
- May 14, 2025, 14:52
- Session
- 2025–2026 Regular Session
- Yeas–nays
- Yeas 102, nays 101
Official record: the roll call on palegis.us ↗
The bill on palegis.us ↗
The chamber on this vote
Seats are today's members, liberal to conservative; members who have left aren't shown.
← Most liberalThe aisleMost conservative →
How each member voted
Yea (102)
- Aerion Abney D-19
- Anthony Bellmon D-203
- Jessica Benham D-36
- Ryan Bizzarro D-3
- Lisa Borowski D-168
- Heather Boyd D-163
- Matt Bradford D-70
- Tim Brennan D-29
- Tim Briggs D-149
- Amen Brown D-10
- Danilo Burgos D-197
- Frank Burns D-72
- Andre Carroll D-201
- Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz D-129
- Morgan Cephas D-192
- Missy Cerrato D-151
- Joe Ciresi D-146
- Scott Conklin D-77
- Gina Curry D-164
- Mary Jo Daley D-148
- Nate Davidson D-103
- Tina Davis D-141
- Jason Dawkins D-179
- Dan Deasy D-27
- Dave Delloso D-162
- Kyle Donahue D-113
- Sean Dougherty D-172
- Elizabeth Fiedler D-184
- Justin Fleming D-105
- Dan Frankel D-23
- Bob Freeman D-136
- Paul Friel D-26
- Pat Gallagher D-173
- José Giral D-180
- Dan Goughnour D-35
- Roni Green D-190
- Nancy Guenst D-152
- Manny Guzman D-127
- Jim Haddock D-118
- Liz Hanbidge D-61
- Pat Harkins D-1
- Jordan Harris D-186
- Keith Harris D-195
- Carol Hill-Evans D-95
- Joe Hohenstein D-177
- Kristine Howard D-167
- John Inglis D-38
- Mary Isaacson D-175
- Carol Kazeem D-159
- Malcolm Kenyatta D-181
- Tarik Khan D-194
- Emily Kinkead D-20
- Bridget Malloy Kosierowski D-114
- Rick Krajewski D-188
- Leanne Krueger D-161
- Anita Kulik D-45
- Maureen Madden D-115
- Dave Madsen D-104
- Steve Malagari D-53
- Brandon Markosek D-25
- Rob Matzie D-16
- La'Tasha Mayes D-24
- Joe McAndrew D-32
- Joanna McClinton D-191
- Jeanne McNeill D-133
- Bob Merski D-2
- Dan Miller D-42
- Kyle Mullins D-112
- Brian Munroe D-144
- Ed Neilson D-174
- Napoleon Nelson D-154
- Jenn O'Mara D-165
- Danielle Otten D-155
- Darisha Parker D-198
- Eddie Pashinski D-121
- Chris Pielli D-156
- Lindsay Powell D-21
- Tarah Probst D-189
- Jim Prokopiak D-140
- Chris Rabb D-200
- Nikki Rivera D-96
- Jacklyn Rusnock D-126
- Abigail Salisbury D-34
- Steve Samuelson D-135
- Ben Sanchez D-153
- Christina Sappey D-158
- Mike Schlossberg D-132
- Pete Schweyer D-134
- Greg Scott D-54
- Melissa Shusterman D-157
- Josh Siegel D-22
- Izzy Smith-Wade-El D-49
- Jared Solomon D-202
- Mandy Steele D-33
- Paul Takac D-82
- Arvind Venkat D-30
- Greg Vitali D-166
- Perry Warren D-31
- Ben Waxman D-182
- Joe Webster D-150
- Dan Williams D-74
- Regina Young D-185
Nay (101)
- Marc Anderson R-92
- Mike Armanini R-75
- Jake Banta R-4
- Scott Barger R-80
- Jamie Barton R-124
- Josh Bashline R-63
- Kerry Benninghoff R-171
- Aaron Bernstine R-8
- Tim Bonner R-17
- Stephanie Borowicz R-76
- Marla Brown R-9
- Marty Causer R-67
- Bud Cook R-50
- Jill Cooper R-55
- Bryan Cutler R-100
- Joe D'Orsie R-47
- Eric Davanzo R-58
- Gary Day R-187
- Sheryl Delozier R-88
- Russ Diamond R-102
- Torren Ecker R-193
- Joe Emrick R-137
- Mindy Fee R-37
- Wendy Fink R-94
- Jamie Flick R-83
- Ann Flood R-138
- Jonathan Fritz R-111
- Valerie Gaydos R-44
- Mark Gillen R-128
- Barb Gleim R-199
- Keith Greiner R-43
- Seth Grove R-196
- Joe Hamm R-84
- Doyle Heffley R-122
- Joe Hogan R-142
- Rich Irvin R-81
- Lee James R-64
- Mike Jones R-93
- Tom Jones R-98
- Josh Kail R-15
- Rob Kauffman R-89
- Dallas Kephart R-73
- Joe Kerwin R-125
- Kate Klunk R-169
- Roman Kozak R-14
- Charity Krupa R-51
- Thomas Kutz R-87
- Andrew Kuzma R-39
- Shelby Labs R-143
- John Lawrence R-13
- Robert Leadbeter R-109
- Milou Mackenzie R-131
- Abby Major R-60
- Zach Mako R-183
- David Maloney R-130
- Kristin Marcell R-178
- Tom Mehaffie R-106
- Steve Mentzer R-97
- Carl Metzgar R-69
- Natalie Mihalek R-40
- Brett Miller R-41
- Dan Moul R-91
- Marci Mustello R-11
- Eric Nelson R-57
- Tim O'Neal R-48
- Jeff Olsommer R-139
- Jason Ortitay R-46
- Clint Owlett R-68
- Tina Pickett R-110
- Brenda Pugh R-120
- Jack Rader R-176
- Kathy Rapp R-65
- Brian Rasel R-56
- Chad Reichard R-90
- Jim Rigby R-71
- Brad Roae R-6
- Leslie Rossi R-59
- David Rowe R-85
- Alec Ryncavage R-119
- Donna Scheuren R-147
- John Schlegel R-101
- Lou Schmitt R-79
- Stephenie Scialabba R-12
- Jeremy Shaffer R-28
- Brian Smith R-66
- Craig Staats R-145
- Perry Stambaugh R-86
- Joanne Stehr R-107
- Michael Stender R-108
- Jim Struzzi R-62
- K.C. Tomlinson R-18
- Jesse Topper R-78
- Tim Twardzik R-123
- Jamie Walsh R-117
- Ryan Warner R-52
- Dane Watro R-116
- Eric Weaknecht R-5
- Parke Wentling R-7
- Martina White R-170
- Craig Williams R-160
- Dave Zimmerman R-99